Um… although, in hindsight, I wonder if you didn’t post this to the wrong thread, Jeff. 
While the responsibility of God is not absent as a topic here, it would seem more relevant to one of Bob’s discussion threads. This thread is not so much about the responsibility of God for evil and suffering, as about the extent of libertarian freedom and whether annihilation is logically consonant with the maintenance and protection of freedom.
Still a fine post, worthy of discussion, but it might fit better over in one of those other threads. 