Dear Lord Jesus,
I am praying to You this night because I am perplexed. I am depressed. I am despairing.
I cannot stop thinking about the Big Picture. I cannot stop thinking about eternal destiny. I do not have peace in my heart. I do not have hope, it seems. Even now that I have jettisoned my belief in eternal suffering, the terrible shadow of Annihilation hangs over me. I am so very sensitive. I am a hyper-sensitive person who feels everything so deeply. You know this, you made me that way.
I have tried to stop thinking about Annihilation, but that is how my obsessive mind works. I vow to put it away in my mind, but again and again it crops up. Even if I do not believe you will subject anyone to eternal misery, how can I have hope when so many will be annihilated out of existence? How can I have hope if one person will be annihilated out of existence?
The thought is so terrible, my Lord, I cannot wrap my head around it. If you annihilate a person, they will never come to know you as you know them. They will never come to know the God who made them and who died for them. Their family members will be eternally bereft of their presence, a presence which, here on earth, was at least of some comfort and joy to them. These annihilated individuals will miss out on an eternity of bless and ever-increasing knowledge of You, Your Father and Your Spirit. They will never know You. How can this be?
Sweet Jesus, can you not save them? I am begging you, my Lord, please save them. Please do not annihilate them (or allow them to annihilate themselves). I cannot judge you, my Lord, but I feel that to annihilate your creatures is so beneath you. Do you not want to save them? Do you want to save them, but are not able? How can I, a wretched sinner, judge You, the King of all? Still, I cannot imagine that You would look upon the unconverted, deliver your harsh sentence with a stony face, then completely obliterate them. Far be it from me to judge you, Lord, but I cannot stand this thought!
Is there no hope for them? How can I have hope when this is the eternal destiny of so many (or any?)
Please save them, Jesus. Please save them. Amen.